Efficacy of neonicotinoid insecticides on Bemisia tabaci and Myzus nicotianae and their non-target effects on tobacco in Western Kenya
Main Article Content
Abstract
The tobacco aphid Myzus persicae subsp. nicotianae and the whitefly Bemisia tabaci are major pests of tobacco and other crops causing stunted growth while transmitting viruses. Two neonicotinoid insecticides; 25WG (Thiamethoxam) and 70WG (Imidacloprid) herein referred to as CSPA (Commercial Synthetic Pesticide A) and CSPB (Commercial Synthetic Pesticide B), respectively are being applied to control the pests in western Kenya. However, there have been growing concerns over insecticide resistance towards these two commercial products. Therefore, two new Imidacloprid insecticides ‘EG 700WP’ and ‘LY 700WDG’ were in the process of being introduced into the market to control the insect pests. The objective of the present study was to determine the efficacy of EG 700WP and LY 700WDG in the control of M. persicae and B. tabaci as well as their non-target effects. These two insecticide formulations were assessed in comparison with CSPA and CSPB through screenhouse and field experiments. Tobacco plants were larger and pest populations lower in all the four insecticide treatements than the control. Tobacco plants treated with LY 700WDG had the lowest populations of B. tabaci and M. nicotianae followed by CSPA then EG 700WP, while CSPB had the highest pest population. Plants treated with LY 700WDG had the largest leaves followed by CSPA then EG 700WP, while those receiving CSPB had the smallest leaves. Viral symptoms were lower in plants that were treated with any of the four insectices compared to the controls, while leaf discoloration tended to be higher in the CSPA and LY 700WDG treatments. Populations of non-target insects were lower in the four insecticide treatments than the controls; with CSPB having a weaker effect than the other three insecticides. In conclusion, the four synthetic insecticides LY 700WDG, EG 700WP, CSPA and CSPB are effective in controlling B. tabaci and M. nicotianae on tobacco plants with the former one having the strongest effect while the latter being relatively weaker. However, the safety of these four insecticides towards non-target organisms would depend on their appropriate use within IPM systems.